M, 80 minutes
4 Stars
Review by © Jane Freebury
The two young Israelis who made this documentary show rare courage, a moral courage that we have seen too little of in recent years. It may result in these filmmakers losing their citizenship. The military intelligence personnel they interviewed will, no doubt, face official retribution if identified, another act of vengeance from a country trying to obscure the truth about its actions in Gaza.
With a nod to the central role of intelligence services in Israel, NAZA opens at night on a rooftop in Tel Aviv. In darkness, members of the IDF appear in shadowy profile, their faces hidden, their voices disguised.
One by one, 24 Israeli military intelligence personnel are interviewed by Yuval Abraham while co-director Rachel Szor wields the camera. Their revelations detail the military system behind the scenes of wretched destruction that have filled our screens for the last three years. In chilling detail, they explain the extent to which artificial intelligence and universal surveillance have been integral to how the Israeli Defense Forces have been identifying and eliminating targets in Gaza.
One young man, who helped develop the system built to profile how a Hamas operative behaves, describes how it works before authorizing a drone to deliver a bomb to those who provide a match. Another man recalls a school trip to Poland in his youth that included a visit to the concentration camps. He wonders what he has become as a result of his role in another system of wholesale killing.
How the Nazi death camps operated on an industrial scale while ordinary Germans were able to carry on their lives next door, featured in the recent film, The Zone of Interest. It was directed by Jonathan Glazer, one of the producers here.
Comfortable urban life despite brutal events unfolding 70 km down the coast
As interviewees respond to Abraham’s questions, the camera roves around the city, a humming metropolis of glass and steel, a blinking giant that never sleeps. People are swimming at the beach, others are jogging along the waterfront. Overhead an enemy rocket streaks across the night sky and is presumably intercepted, while people at home in the building opposite, visible through apartment windows as they watch the news on TV, follow their fitness routines or clear up in the kitchen, remain undeterred. A collage of images of comfortable urban life despite the brutal events unfolding 70 km down the coast.
Archival footage inserts relevant history here and there. Intelligence officers listen in on family conversations—the telecommunications network in Gaza, set up by the Israelis in the 1960s, allows the IDF to hack and locate phones. Figuring that the odds were best when targets were home at night rather than out and about with fellow combatants in the day, Israeli drones dropped bombs on targets and their families while they were in bed.
We shouldn’t be surprised by this. The Israeli president and others in the political elite have, in the aftermath of October 7, said there were no innocent Palestinians. The concept of collateral damage, the term that NAZA apparently refers to, has become a viciously distorted concept in this asymmetrical war.
The young Israeli operatives are invited by Abraham to reflect on their work. Hearing the final moments of people’s lives, some admitted, instilled memories that were hard to erase. Others acknowledged an adrenaline rush after completing a successful mission—and went out to lunch with friends. I wonder how this dreadful chapter will impact the lives of young Israeli combatants into the future.
A chilling, nightmarish vision of a future run with AI and universal surveillance
The personal journey of investigative journalists-turned-filmmakers, Abraham and Szor, began with No Other Land, another devastating record of Israeli violence against Palestinians, but in the West Bank. That first feature, recording armed settlers robbing Palestinian families of their land and livelihood, has won multiple best documentary feature film awards, including an Academy Award, across the US, Europe and beyond.
No Other Land was filmed almost entirely before Hamas breached Israeli defences so brutally on 7 October 2023. It however exposes violence of a different order, the brutal dispossession that has been taking place for decades with the growth of illegal Israeli settlements across Palestinians territories.
As a cold, impersonal nightmare vision of a future run by AI, our shared humanity excised, NAZA needs to be seen. While international agencies have been vocal, the silence about Gaza at government and community level is deeply disturbing, but these two young film directors, Abraham and Szor, have stepped into the breach.
Many in my generation were once inspired by the story of Israel, a story celebrated with films like Exodus. Some, like me, even volunteered at a kibbutz for a while, but that was long ago and in another country.
Also published on Rotten Tomatoes
NAZA will stream on The Guardian website from early December and on DocPlay in January 2027
Featured image from NAZA courtesy Madman Entertainment, The Guardian